If you’re keen on sculpting your physique and packing on muscle, you might think the pathway is clear: embark on a bulking phase, as many might suggest in the world of fitness. But is this traditional method of ‘eating big to get big’ always the best strategy to enhance muscle mass? Today, we delve into the nuances of muscle building, challenging the conventional bulking approach and offering insights on how you can achieve muscle growth without necessarily entering a calorie surplus.
The information used for this article is largely based on a video shared by Jeremy Ethier. Jeremy Ethier is a kinesiologist and fitness trainer, co-founder of Built With Science. His YouTube channel has over 6.4 million subscribers and he delivers clear information with sound background research.
Jeremy Ethier delves into the intricacies of muscle building, offering a nuanced perspective that challenges the traditional bulking paradigm. He begins by reflecting on his own journey, where his initial foray into the world of fitness was marked by a steadfast adherence to the ‘eat big to get big’ mantra. His experience, which involved consuming an almost astronomical amount of milk daily, led to a pivotal realisation: the gains he achieved were not as lean as he had hoped. This personal revelation spurred Jeremy to question the conventional wisdom surrounding muscle growth.
Related: Ultimate Guide on How to Get Shredded
How to Build Muscle Without Bulking (New Research)
Through a meticulous examination of a 2021 meta-analysis—a study that synthesizes findings from various research endeavours—Jeremy provides a compelling argument that bulking is not a one-size-fits-all solution for muscle development. The meta-analysis, which compared muscle growth outcomes across different nutritional strategies, unveiled that strength gains were consistent irrespective of caloric intake. However, when it came to muscle hypertrophy, the situation was more complex. Notably, while a calorie deficit often resulted in muscle loss, not every study under calorie-restricted conditions led to such outcomes. It was particularly intriguing that a minor deficit could still support muscle growth, debunking the notion that a caloric surplus is indispensable for building muscle.
To further substantiate his argument, Jeremy turned to the insights of Dr. Eric Helms, an authority in natural bodybuilding and fitness science. His insights, drawn from a comprehensive review in the Strength and Conditioning Journal, confirmed that achieving muscle growth while shedding fat is indeed feasible, especially for individuals not satisfied with their current body fat levels.
But how does this translate into practical advice for fitness enthusiasts? Let’s explore the strategic adjustments required for different individuals, based on their training status and goals.
Related: 7 Ways to Look More Muscular
Note: other scientific studies used for the information can be found here and here.
Beginners: The Newbie Phase
If you’re new to resistance training, your body is primed for rapid muscle growth, a phenomenon often termed ‘newbie gains.’ During this phase, a more pronounced calorie surplus can be beneficial. Aiming for a 2% body weight increase per month by adopting a daily surplus of 400-500 calories can fuel significant muscle gains while keeping fat accumulation in check.
Intermediate and Advanced Lifters: Fine-Tuning the Approach
As you progress, your muscle growth rate decelerates. For intermediate lifters, scaling back to a 1% body weight increase per month by adopting a modest surplus of 200-300 calories can strike a balance between muscle development and minimal fat gain. Advanced lifters need to be even more meticulous, aiming for a marginal surplus that aligns with their slower potential for muscle growth.
Read This Too: The Optimal Rest Time for Muscle And Strength Gains
Individual Preferences and Goals
It’s crucial to align your nutrition strategy with your aesthetic and performance objectives. Some might prioritize lean gains, focusing on a slight surplus or maintenance, especially if starting from a higher body fat percentage. Others may opt for a more pronounced surplus to maximize muscle growth, understanding that it comes with increased fat gain, which can be addressed later.
Practical Tips for Muscle Building Without Bulking
- Protein Intake: Ensure your diet is rich in protein to support muscle repair and growth.
- Strength Training: Consistently challenge your muscles through progressive overload in your training regimen.
- Monitor Progress: Use changes in strength, body composition, and weight as guides to adjust your caloric intake.
- Nutrient Timing: While not as crucial as total intake, distributing protein intake throughout the day can support muscle synthesis.
- Rest and Recovery: Adequate sleep and rest days are vital to allow your muscles to recover and grow.
In conclusion, while bulking can be a pathway to muscle growth, it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution. Depending on your starting point, goals, and training status, a more nuanced approach might yield better, more sustainable results. Engage with your body’s signals, adapt your nutrition and training strategies accordingly, and remember that muscle building is a marathon, not a sprint.
Watch Ethier’s video in which he explains in further detail how to build muscle without bulking.
Read Also: The Best Training Technique to Build Muscle in Half the Time
Real building of the muscle is founded on resistance to the point of causing micro-tears in the fibers of the muscle. The tearing, when repaired, causes the muscle to grow stronger and often larger. The effective routine of muscle building should ensure consistency in working out all major body muscles with various forms of exercise. This program should be composed of compound movements that engage the whole body, working its muscular groups, and isolation exercises such as bicep curls and leg extensions.
The principle of progressive overload is basically the basis of muscle building; it refers to a gradual increase of the stress applied to the muscles as one undertakes exercise. Only in such a way will muscle tissue receive the stimuli necessary for growth, such as regular increase in weights, reps, or intensity of the workout. This is a progressive challenge that ensures the muscles never get used to being under the same level of stress. Therefore, continual growth and improvement can be achieved. Without progressive overload, muscle development can get to a point of plateau, thus allowing further gain to be very challenging.
Selection of exercises and organizing a workout represents the crucible in muscle building. Proper selection of exercises in the above way will allow one to design a program with an even distribution of exercises throughout all the muscle groups, allowing recovery, and both preventing overtraining and promoting symmetrical muscle growth. The frequency of working out is also paramount. Most of the ideal recommendations will lead you to indicate each group is exercised in between 2-3 times a week, in order to optimally stimulate and recover.
Nutrition plays an equally vital role in muscle growth. Therefore, sufficient proteins are an important requirement since they are the main building block of muscle. It follows that sufficient proteins in the body are required for the repairing and building of the muscle tissues from exercising. Other important nutrients that should feature in a balanced diet include carbohydrates, fats, among others, in order to provide the body with the necessary energy either for workouts or for its overall operation. Remaining with some surplus caloric intake might be helpful in muscle gain, where some additional energy is demanded by the body for the purpose of laying up new muscle tissues.
Finally, the most likely to be unnoticed is rest and recovery in the muscle building process. The real building up of the muscle happens during rest and not while doing the exercise. Ensuring adequate sleep and allowing proper time for muscles to recover are key, as overtraining may end in fatigue, injury, or even muscle loss, negating the muscle-building effort. Effective muscle building incorporates rest days, focus on sleep quality, and stress management.
Read More: New Study Suggests You Don’t Need a Big Caloric Surplus to Build Muscle